One I wanted, the other I bought. Take home message, don't settle!
I hate the one I bought, every time I sit on it.
I did leave the tags on it, aren't letting the kids near it, and attempting to sell it on Craigs List. If it sells, I will immediately go get the slight animal print, over sized, crazy looking chaise that will make ME SMILE EVERY TIME MY BUTT SITS IN IT. :)
(UPDATE: 6 months later, I went and bought the big chaise. Every person who enters my house sits in it and loves it! I kept the other chaise as well. It fits in the kids' reading area...)